OK, so now that I've got Halo : Reach, and my new 360 and an actual internet connection between my 360 and PC - I'm gonna set up my Live. I USED to have a GT on my old console, and it's still up on Xbox.com and whatnot, so I can't use the same e-mail; therein lies the problem. The e-mail I set up is my main e-mail so I don't want to use another one, but I can't for the life of me, figure out how to delete my Xbox.com account
Anyone know how the hell I can make a new gamertag on this 360 with the same e-mail?
Why don't you just recover your old gamertag?