I enjoyed Reanimator and From Beyond, even though they were both horrible movies, neither of which got anywhere near the correct atmosphere. I thought Dagon was mildly entertaining as well. But there hasn't be a single movie yet to get the atmosphere right or to even grasp what interested Lovecraft. There have been a few movies "influenced" by Lovecraft who did it much better.
It annoyed me so much that in my screenwriting class in college, I wrote a screenplay called "Among Us" that was basically entirely built around the idea that no one had ever gotten the Lovecraft atmosphere right, even though it's not difficult to do if you actually read Lovecraft. The teacher said I should be a professional screenwriter after he read it. It wasn't based off of any specific Lovecraft story, but was written in a style that would get across Lovecraft's themes, atmosphere, and sense of horror.
