Metal Guitarist Forums banner
1 - 20 of 22 Posts

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
316 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·





Anyone gave this a listen yet? I definitely like parts. It also seems like a mesh of Cynic and Aeon Spoke.
 

·
DOO)))M
Joined
·
7,435 Posts
I really enjoyed it, probably because it's so different from the approach everyone is doing today of 'super technical and super fast' so to have a band who's already done a very technical album - that's not blazing fast - and say, "Let's strip it down to the core" was cool
 

·
Chromaphonic Invader
Joined
·
1,298 Posts
I've never really listened to them before, but they sound a lot like Porcupine Tree in those songs to me. Too much so for me to like it.
 

·
DOO)))M
Joined
·
7,435 Posts
I've never really listened to them before, but they sound a lot like Porcupine Tree in those songs to me. Too much so for me to like it.
I'd say listen to the originals first :

King of Those Who Know (King)
Evolutionary Sleeper (Evolutionary)
Integral Birth (Integral)
Space For This (Space)

Wheels Within Wheels is a new one possibly done specifically for this, so there's no previous version
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
7,428 Posts
I really enjoyed it, probably because it's so different from the approach everyone is doing today of 'super technical and super fast' so to have a band who's already done a very technical album - that's not blazing fast - and say, "Let's strip it down to the core" was cool
While TIA was still really good and still quite technical without sounding retarded, I still found it was striped compared to focus, which is why I find this one too stripped.
 

·
DOO)))M
Joined
·
7,435 Posts
While TIA was still really good and still quite technical without sounding retarded, I still found it was striped compared to focus, which is why I find this one too stripped.
I uh, haven't heard ...Focus yet :ugh:
 

·
Señor Member
Joined
·
12,297 Posts
The concert of them playing Hovefestivalen is a must watch. I believe they play all the songs off of Focus, and they also play an original version of Evolutionary Sleeper that's pretty awesome.

I mention it because I loved Focus but the mix made it hard for me to enjoy, while I think quality of that concert did the songs descent justice.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
7,428 Posts
The concert of them playing Hovefestivalen is a must watch. I believe they play all the songs off of Focus, and they also play an original version of Evolutionary Sleeper that's pretty awesome.

I mention it because I loved Focus but the mix made it hard for me to enjoy, while I think quality of that concert did the songs descent justice.
Too true, I never really got into Cynic until I could get over the terribe, terrible recording job that was Focus :lol:
 

·
DOO)))M
Joined
·
7,435 Posts
Have you heard the re-mastered version? They only re-mastered a few tracks anyways, and it all still sounds like shit. Just mildly different :lol:

They should just re-record the album from scratch.
Since my disc drive is broken I've yet to buy the album, and when I tried DL'ing it stayed at 0% for like 4 days :lol: So no.
 

·
Señor Member
Joined
·
12,297 Posts
Also, don't let the fact that Paul and Tymon are fantastic players overshadow what an influence Jason Gobel was on the "sound of Cynic". He's did a lot of the heavy lifting on tracks like How Could I, which has to be my favorite solo of all time and one of my favorite songs as a whole.

In much the same fashion, Sean Malone is and was a fucking stud. Robin and Chris held onto a lot of the style and vibe, but Sean is the original (as Gordian Knot pretty much proved).

So, you have Traced In Air. I actually like the album as a whole better than Focus, but Veil of Maya and How Could I are still the two best songs that band ever wrote, IMO. Having Paul, Malone, and Reinert back in the studio when they did TiA gave it some of it's magic, along with the pent up decade of music that they had waiting as their answer to the first album.

Which brings me to Re-traced. It's like... it wants to be very original and true to form, but it's just not there. Feels like without Malone or Gobel there, Paul just kinda did whatever the hell he wanted to do with it. Enter Aeon Spoke v2.0. It's neat on it's own, I don't hate it... but... meh.

I love Tymon, Robin and the rest of them but Cynic is and was the original line-up, IMO... and this last album is evidence of that.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
7,428 Posts
Also, don't let the fact that Paul and Tymon are fantastic players overshadow what an influence Jason Gobel was on the "sound of Cynic". He's did a lot of the heavy lifting on tracks like How Could I, which has to be my favorite solo of all time and one of my favorite songs as a whole.

In much the same fashion, Sean Malone is and was a fucking stud. Robin and Chris held onto a lot of the style and vibe, but Sean is the original (as Gordian Knot pretty much proved).

So, you have Traced In Air. I actually like the album as a whole better than Focus, but Veil of Maya and How Could I are still the two best songs that band ever wrote, IMO. Having Paul, Malone, and Reinert back in the studio when they did TiA gave it some of it's magic, along with the pent up decade of music that they had waiting as their answer to the first album.

Which brings me to Re-traced. It's like... it wants to be very original and true to form, but it's just not there. Feels like without Malone or Gobel there, Paul just kinda did whatever the hell he wanted to do with it. Enter Aeon Spoke v2.0. It's neat on it's own, I don't hate it... but... meh.

I love Tymon, Robin and the rest of them but Cynic is and was the original line-up, IMO... and this last album is evidence of that.
Yes, Malones basswork is fucking genious :steve:
 
1 - 20 of 22 Posts
Top